Judge rejects Aetna's plan to buy rival health insurer Humana

Jan 24, 2017, 00:27
Judge rejects Aetna's plan to buy rival health insurer Humana

The Aetna-Humana deal is not the only mega-merger between insurers that's now under scrutiny: The proposed $54 billion merger between Anthem and Cigna also faces suit from the Department of Justice over antitrust concerns.

U.S. District Judge John Bates found that to be the case, writing in his decision that, "the merger of Aetna and Humana would be likely to substantially lessen competition in markets for individual Medicare Advantage plans and health insurance sold on the public exchanges", in 364 counties.

"In that market, which is the primary focus of this case, the merger is presumptively unlawful-a conclusion that is strongly supported by direct evidence of head-to-head competition as well", Bates writes.

An Aetna spokesman says the insurer is reviewing the opinion, and it will give "serious consideration to an appeal". Several news sources previously reported that the mega-merger faced an "uphill battle" in convincing antitrust regulators that consumers wouldn't be harmed by the deal and would in fact benefit from it.

A U.S. District Court is also considering a DOJ suit to block another proposed merger between Anthem and Cigna.

While the ruling could kill the merger, Aetna and Humana could appeal the decision. Humana is the second-largest Medicare Advantage insurer, while Aetna is the fourth biggest.

"Elderly patients were the big winners today", Gurman said. "The wrinkle here is that shortly after the complaint was filed, Aetna announced that it would no longer offer on-exchange plans for 2017 in any of those 17 counties".

Bates' opinion marks a significant setback for the companies, which previous year announced the proposed deal to create the largest seller of Medicare Advantage plans, covering more than 4.1 million seniors.

Aetna updated its forecast in November and said for 2016 it expected to post a pre-tax loss of $350 million. Because the Medicare Advantage market is already heavily consolidated, "there are few large combinations in the industry that would seem feasible", he said. U.S. District Judge Amy Berman Jackson is expected to issue a ruling this month on that merger following a non-jury trial late previous year. That case hinges on whether the merger will reduce competition in the national market, so it's unlikely that decision in the Aetna-Humana case will have much influence over Jackson's decision, said Tim Greaney, co-director of the Center for Health Law Studies at St. Louis University. Shares of Cigna (CI) and Anthem (ANTM) also fell, as their $44 billion merger has also been challenged by the FTC and a judge's ruling is pending.

YOU MIGHT ALSO LIKE
  • Northern Ireland's Sinn Fein hands reins to new generation

    Northern Ireland's Sinn Fein hands reins to new generation

    Michelle O'Neill has been chosen to replace Martin McGuinness as Sinn Féin's new leader of the north. Sinn Fein president Gerry Adams said Ms O'Neill represented a "new generation" for the party.
    Preview for ECB Rate Decision and Outlook for EUR-crosses

    Preview for ECB Rate Decision and Outlook for EUR-crosses

    It comes amid growing anger in Germany over European Central Bank policies, with the eurozone's largest economy seeing a large rise in inflation.

    Anti-Trump protesters drop banners from London bridges

    Sister Ann Tici Pation said: "The order indicts Donald J Trump, and all his greedy, self-serving minions, for sins against decency".
  • President Trump Open to Joint Russia-US Strikes In Syria

    President Trump Open to Joint Russia-US Strikes In Syria

    "The Department of Defense is not coordinating airstrikes with the Russian military in Syria", Rankine-Galloway said. Moscow supports Syrian President Bashar Assad in the country's almost 6-year-old civil war.
    Egypt Snatch Late Winner To Eliminate Onyango's Uganda

    Egypt Snatch Late Winner To Eliminate Onyango's Uganda

    The pitch in Port-Gentil is in a bad condition and Grant said: "We want to qualify and we want to play on a good pitch". The Pharaohs drew the first match 0-0 against Mali .
    Flu season at its peak, shots are encouraged

    Flu season at its peak, shots are encouraged

    Flu vaccines are available at doctors' offices and pharmacies. "We anticipate there will be good efficacy this year", he said. Officials say a total of 311 people have been hospitalized or died from the flu since September 1st, 2016.
  • Marvel at these first pics from a next-gen weather satellite

    Marvel at these first pics from a next-gen weather satellite

    This augmented capability will be invaluable for forecasters, especially when tracking potentially risky storms. The first images from NOAA's next-generation weather satellite are in and they're absolutely stunning.

    Kansas City Royals Pitcher Yordano Ventura Killed In Car Crash

    Ventura, also born in the Dominican Republic, was a 25-year-old pitcher for the Kansas City Royals . The deaths of Marte and Ventura come just months after Major League Baseball lost Jose Fernandez .

    Its official, 2016 was the hottest year ever recorded

    Global average temperatures during 2016 were 0.99 degrees warmer than the mid-20th century average. For the contiguous Unites States, 2016 actually was the second warmest year on record .
  • Alec Baldwin Sets 'Saturday Night Live' Return as Host

    Alec Baldwin Sets 'Saturday Night Live' Return as Host

    Trump has not taken too kindly to Baldwin's impression of him, tweeting that it "just can't get any worse" and calling it "sad". The NBC show said Monday that Baldwin will host the February 11 show.

    Daesh Terrorists Destroy Part of Roman Theater in Palmyra

    But in December Islamic militants regained control of the world heritage site and they are now exacting revenge by destroying it. Daesh controlled the Palmyra site after capturing it in December for a second time from the Syrian government forces.

    China Ready to Negotiate Trade Terms with Trump Administration

    China is protesting the attendance of Taiwan's delegation headed by a former premier at Donald Trump's inauguration Friday. China will send its ambassador to the US, Cui Tiankai, to the inauguration.
popular